St. Anastasia has been lead by seven pastors:

Rev. John A. Fleming- Founding Pastor 1926-1931

Msgr. Joseph F. Cussen- Second Pastor 1931-1936

Msgr. Joseph A. Garrity- Third Pastor  1936-1961

Msgr. Joseph D. Connerton- Fourth Pastor 1961-1971

Rev. Edward S. Maraczewski- Fifth Pastor 1971-1987

Rev. Terrence McCarthy-  Sixth Pastor 1987- 2001

Rev. Aloysius Funtila - Seventh Pastor 2001 - present